FLK1 · Multiple-choice practice
FLK1 Dispute Resolution — Question 31
Try this question in the test bank →Question
In a civil trial, a dispute arises regarding the quality of construction work performed by a contractor on a commercial building. The plaintiff, a property management company, alleges that the defendant contractor’s workmanship was substandard, resulting in structural issues and safety concerns. As part of their case, the plaintiff intends to call an expert witness, Dr. Smith, who has a Ph.D. in civil engineering with extensive experience in building construction and structural analysis. However, the defendant objects to Dr. Smith’s qualifications, arguing that although Dr. Smith is knowledgeable in civil engineering, their expertise does not specifically relate to commercial building construction. Which legal principle governs the admissibility of expert testimony in this scenario?
Answer and explanation
Correct answer: D. The rule of admissibility
The admissibility of expert testimony in court proceedings is governed by the rule of admissibility. According to this rule, an expert witness will be permitted to testify if the court determines that they are qualified in the subject matter requiring their expertise. While it is generally expected that an expert witness will possess appropriate qualifications and experience in the relevant field, it is not always necessary that they have specific professional qualifications related to the subject matter of the dispute. In this scenario, Dr. Smith’s qualifications in civil engineering, combined with their experience in building construction and structural analysis, may still render them competent to provide expert testimony on the quality of construction work, despite the defendant’s objection. Ultimately, it is up to the trial judge to assess Dr. Smith’s qualifications and determine whether their expertise is sufficiently relevant and reliable to be admitted as evidence in the case.
Original newsletter explanation ↗Continue in the test bank for scoring, feedback, progress tracking and timed mini mocks.
More FLK1 Dispute Resolution questions →